A calculator may generate a rough range, but in Niles claims are still decided by Michigan-specific realities and the facts of the crash—especially liability disputes.
In many motorcycle cases, the insurer’s first position isn’t only about injury severity. It’s also about whether the rider’s conduct contributed to the crash. Michigan follows comparative fault, meaning even if you weren’t the main cause, an insurer may reduce settlement value based on a percentage of fault.
Local takeaway: If your settlement estimate feels “too low” or “too high,” it’s often because the estimate can’t accurately reflect local evidence—like witness clarity, traffic light timing, road conditions, and whether the other driver’s version holds up.


