Most settlement calculators produce a broad range using simplified inputs—often things like the seriousness of injury, past costs, or general injury categories.
In Montclair cases, that “generic range” can be misleading because real disputes often hinge on details such as:
- Whether the chart supports the timeline (what happened, when it was noticed, and what was ordered)
- Whether experts agree the harm was preventable under the applicable standard of care
- Whether later treatment was reasonable or whether it broke the causal chain
A calculator may give you a starting point. But it won’t review imaging, operative reports, pharmacy records, or deposition testimony—the evidence that actually drives value in California negotiations.


