You may have searched online for a dog bite settlement calculator, but insurers don’t negotiate based on a formula. In Garner cases, value usually turns on what can be proven:
- How severe the bite was (deep punctures, infection, scarring, reduced function)
- What medical providers documented (ER notes, follow-ups, imaging, wound descriptions)
- Who can confirm what happened (witnesses, video, incident reports)
- How the dog was controlled at the time of the bite
A quick online tool can be useful as a starting point, but it often misses the factors that matter most in North Carolina claims—like inconsistencies in early accounts, gaps in treatment, or defenses focused on “provocation” or “no fault.”


