Online tools can help you think through categories of damages, but they can’t see the details that insurers focus on in Western New York.
In practice, settlement value tends to turn on:
- Medical documentation quality (ER notes, follow-up records, imaging if needed)
- Whether the injury is treated as a serious wound or becomes “minor” on paper
- How liability is framed—for example, whether the dog was leashed/controlled or whether the incident happened in a place where the injured person had a right to be
- Consistency over time—your timeline, photos, witness accounts, and medical history need to line up
Because of that, two people can be bitten in similar ways and still see very different outcomes once the evidence is reviewed.


