Online tools are limited because they can’t measure the things insurers actually argue about in New Jersey. In Westfield, common disputes include:
- Whether the bite was foreseeable (for example, whether the dog showed agitation before the incident)
- Whether the dog was restrained when contact occurred (leash control, fencing, supervision)
- Where the incident happened—a private home visit versus a public-facing situation can change what witnesses saw and what defenses are raised
- Whether your actions contributed to the insurer’s comparative-fault theory
New Jersey uses comparative negligence, so even if the dog owner is largely responsible, your settlement can be reduced if the defense claims you acted in a way that increased risk. That’s one reason the “number” from a calculator can be misleading if it doesn’t reflect your specific facts.


