In smaller communities like Union, people often assume fault will be obvious. But disputes are common, especially when the incident happened in a setting where facts can be questioned—such as:
- Visitor or delivery situations (packages, contractors, or guests arriving at a home)
- Neighborhood sidewalks and driveways where a dog may have been off-leash or not properly restrained
- Backyard or porch encounters where warnings may be argued to exist (or not)
Insurers frequently challenge one or more of the following:
- Whether the owner had reasonable control of the dog
- Whether the dog’s behavior was foreseeable based on prior history
- Whether the injured person’s actions were treated as a justification/defense
- Whether the medical injuries are clearly connected to the bite
Because of this, two bites that look similar initially can lead to very different outcomes once an adjuster reviews the evidence.


