In many cases, the dispute isn’t about whether a bite occurred—it’s about why it happened and who had reasonable control of the dog at the time.
Common arguments you may see in Castle Pines:
- Owner claims the dog was provoked. For example, if a child approached, a person startled the dog, or a confrontation occurred.
- Control and restraint defenses. The owner may argue the dog was leashed, contained, or not acting aggressively in a foreseeable way.
- “It wasn’t our dog / it was trespass.” In neighborhoods and near shared paths, the facts of where the bite occurred can matter.
- Injury causation disputes. Insurance may argue that an infection, pain, or follow-up treatment is unrelated to the bite.
Because these disputes are typical, it’s important to treat the early phase of your claim carefully—what you say to an adjuster, what documentation you keep, and how quickly you seek treatment.


