Most AI tools work by asking for basic details—age, relationship, medical bills, employment, and incident type—and then generating a range. That range may be directionally helpful, but it’s not case-specific.
In Scarsdale, the reason these tools often fall short is usually the same: liability in fatal cases turns on proof, and proof depends on the scene, timing, and documents. For example:
- Crash cases may hinge on traffic control devices, witness statements, video footage, and vehicle data.
- Late-emerging medical complications may require careful medical causation review.
- Disputes can arise over whether a driver’s conduct was a substantial factor in the death.
A calculator can’t obtain police reports, preserve electronic evidence, interpret medical records, or evaluate how a New York jury might view contested facts.


