In Berkeley, it’s not unusual for insurers to argue about fault even when the police report seems clear. Urban traffic patterns—right turns with pedestrians nearby, lane changes in dense corridors, sudden stops near crosswalks, and crashes involving bikes or scooters—create details adjusters try to reframe.
If the other driver is uninsured, the dispute may shift toward:
- Causation (whether the crash actually caused or aggravated your injuries)
- Comparative fault (even small arguments can lower settlement value)
- Coverage timing (whether you reported and documented quickly enough under the policy)
Your early evidence matters because it’s what the insurer will review when deciding whether to pay—or how much to offer.


