Many AI tools estimate damages by asking for inputs like injury severity, treatment length, and lost income. That can be helpful for orientation.
However, in New York trucking claims, settlement value often hinges on disputes that generic software can’t model well, such as:
- Whether the trucking company’s policies and maintenance records will support (or undermine) negligence.
- Causation fights—for example, whether an insurer argues symptoms were pre-existing or unrelated.
- Comparative fault arguments—even where the truck driver appears at fault, insurers may try to shift responsibility.
- Documentation gaps—missing imaging, delayed treatment, or inconsistent symptom reporting.
A calculator may produce a range, but it can’t tell you whether your case will be treated as “fully documented” or “uncertain,” and insurers pay very close attention to that distinction.


