Goshen residents and visitors often move through the same kinds of locations—shopping corridors, apartment communities, service businesses, and parking areas. Negligent security issues tend to arise where conditions make confrontations more likely or harder to prevent.
You may have a case if the incident happened in situations like:
- Parking lot or driveway assaults: Poor lighting, blocked sightlines, unsecured entry points, or cameras that don’t cover the area where harm occurred.
- Apartment and multi-unit common areas: Broken locks, door propping, lack of functional access systems, or delayed response to threats.
- Businesses with limited supervision: Security staff who weren’t present when they should have been, inadequate procedures for responding to reports of stalking, threats, or disturbances.
- After-hours harm near entrances: Incidents that occur when foot traffic is lower but the risk is still foreseeable—especially where the property does not adjust lighting or monitoring.
Even where the attacker is not an employee, the question is usually whether the property owner’s security choices were reasonable in light of what they knew (or should have known).


