After a part failure, insurance companies and defense counsel commonly argue one of two things:
- The defect wasn’t the cause—they claim the crash was due to maintenance, driving behavior, or something unrelated.
- The defect wasn’t there yet—they argue the problem only showed up after repairs, replacements, or diagnostic work.
In real life, delays happen. Vehicles get towed. Shops diagnose and replace components. Data logs may be pulled. Parts may be discarded. And in New York, claim deadlines and insurance procedures move on a schedule—even if your recovery or the investigation takes time.
That’s why we prioritize a simple goal early: lock in the facts while they still exist.


