In many injury cases, the dispute isn’t whether you’re hurt. It’s whether the other party’s actions caused the specific fracture and whether the injury matches the accident you reported.
After a crash on a busy corridor, a fall in a retail area, or a workplace incident, insurers may argue:
- the fracture was pre-existing
- the injury could have come from a different event
- the mechanism of injury doesn’t “fit” the medical findings
In Murphy, where many residents drive to work and handle tight schedules, these disputes are especially frustrating because you may have already missed work and started treatment before the paperwork conflict fully surfaces.


